Well today something out of the ordinary happened; this morning was going as per usual at school. I arrived early and started organising my day and then I had a couple of parents wanting to speak to me.
In my primary class 1 class or 6 and 7 year olds, I have a handful of what Thais call Luk Krung or half foreigner, half Thai. One of their students had reported something that had made their father concerned.
In my class I had used these words to a student, “I will throw you out the window.” Now this does sound severe and something that would petrify a young learner but it was in no such way.
Anyway, the father raised his concern, and then we had a discussion about a certain student, I will call “A”. I directed these comments to A, as he is a handful and a half. The parents know this and that he is very disruptive.
“A” is a special student, he can read and do a lot of the activities in the classroom, but his writing is terrible and nearly impossible to read, his attention span is seconds and he never listens to instructions. He continually stands up and plays with anything in range of him.
I virtually have to remove everything from him before the class starts, as he plays with anything near him, he talks to himself out loud and also yells noises at times in the middle of activities.
I know his mother, have for 4 years and she was so concerned when he was in kindergarten they took him to a specialist to see if they could diagnose a problem such as ADD pr such I suppose.
She came in to see me not long after school started after she saw some of his scores for in class work, and also notes written in his workbook. She asked what she could do to help “A.”
I honestly told her I had no idea or could offer any advice on how “A” could be helped. I am not a specialist or have any experience in such cases. I cannot teach such students as there are special ways to teach them and I have no idea how to approach this.
Anyway, so “A” has a problem, not sure what, it could be immaturity or something else. But at times he does really get to you in the classroom. After telling him numerous times to sit down or taking him back to his seat as he is annoying other students, stop talking to himself or yelling out, playing with anything and everything, you do get short.
I have said to “A” a few times after so many warning in a class, “A sit down or I will throw you out the window.” Never with malice, but yes, I said it. To a 7 year old maybe this is not so good as they are young in mind and naive.
Anyway back to the father, so after raising his concerns and then giving me a small lecture or advice on what and how a teacher should conduct himself and speak, he asked that I apologise to the students as he thought I was way out of line. This I did in the class to make sure the students understood I was not serious about what I said to “A”
The parent was an educator for 10 years he told me in his country and he never lost it or said anything like this untoward his students. He did offer one bit of advice to me that I thought was completely oddball or way off kilter, he could read this blog and so be it, but to me this was weird.
He said to me, that no matter how angry or whatever you are you cannot show this in the classroom, so if you feel getting like this, take 10 seconds out and then this, “think what Jesus would do”
Now I have no fucking idea what Jesus would have done as I don’t read the bible and think religion is a load of shit. That is me personally and to any religious people reading this, it is my view. You continue worshipping your fable gods if this is what you are happy doing. I have no gripes with anyone following a religion, do so but don’t preach it onto me.
When he said this to me, I lost concentration as it was bouncing around in my head then. I was thinking what the hell he meant. I was then thinking if he was a bible kook or such but he seemed really nice, passionate and a concerned parent.
So can anyone offer me the answer to what Jesus would do in such a situation? Would he turn water into wine, part waters or such? He was a teacher, wasn’t he? Wasn’t he a carpenter as well?
The father also said some thing that didn’t add up to me. He made good points about teaching and how to conduct yourself but the suggestions on how to control “A” were not what I consider right.
He asked if we had a time out room or discipline room like we have back in our countries, I informed him we didn’t. Then make him sit on the floor, by him self outside and so forth.
I have had “A” totally isolated from other students and near as possible to me so in the hope of being able to control him or keep his focus, but no such luck. Sending him outside the room unsupervised for a few minutes is too dangerous as he could wander off and end up on the busy main road, now this would be terrible. But as the saying goes when kids annoy you, “go play on the road”.
Trying to see what makes “A” happy, what gets his attention and keeps him happy I haven’t found, yet. I have used colouring sheets, draw pictures, games and such to no avail.
The parent said to give him comic book and let him do whatever for the 50 minutes and then pass him onto the next teacher and let him be their problem. This I would love to do, but I want him to learn, I know he does learn and understand as he can do the work orally, read words and also identify flashcards.
So, what to do? No more threatening to throw him out the window, seriously or jokingly. This also means no other advice like, “take a long walk off a short pier”, “jump out of a plane without a parachute”, “play Russian roulette with a fully loaded gun” as “A” or the kids could take it to heart and literally.
I am open to criticism as I am not perfect and do make mistakes. I say things off the cuff and so forth but that is me. I am not Jesus and never want to be anything like what he is supposed to have been.
I am me, and stone me to death for this. I am sure there are readers out there who would like to. But I am not going to change myself. I will try and make sure off the cuff remarks are kept to myself and are just thoughts in my head and not actually said aloud. “Man I could give this kid a huge kick in their ass” or “if they speak once more when I am talking I am going to stick a dirty sock down their throat”
I will still get satisfaction from the thought, but will not have said anything and just have a dumb and amusing grin on my face in front of the kids.
Brunty
11 comments:
Brunty, you can only do what you can. That educator/parent overstated Thai teachers' conducts. I was educated there until high school and knew that wasn't the case. Teachers are humans, too, and are entitled to losing temper once in a while. But, let me assure you that some Thai teachers are much worse than you and their conducts much much more disturbing.
Top
Regarding Jesus, I have no idea, either. I wasn't born yet and neither was that educator/teacher. Besides, despite the claim that the biblical texts are the word of God, it was actually humans and the abusive church hierarchy that put them together for social control purpose. So, don't get discouraged by these knuckle-head-good-for-nothing-christian shenanigans. I do believe there are good christians out there. But, good christians don't just use their prophet and savior to fulfill their ego and fantasy.
Brunty, you can only do what you can. That educator/parent overstated Thai teachers' conducts. I was educated there until high school and knew that wasn't the case. Teachers are humans, too, and are entitled to losing temper once in a while. But, let me assure you that some Thai teachers are much worse than you and their conducts much much more disturbing.
Regarding Jesus, I have no idea, either. I wasn't born yet and neither was that educator/teacher. Besides, despite the claim that the biblical texts are the word of God, it was actually humans and the abusive church hierarchy that put them together for social control purpose. So, don't get discouraged by these knuckle-head-good-for-nothing-christian shenanigans. I do believe there are good christians out there. But, good christians don't just use their prophet and savior to fulfill their ego and fantasy.
Ah, the trials of teaching! I remember them well. Even trained specialist teachers struggle with students with the behaviors of the student you described. Perhaps a starting point might be to do a little reading about strategies which have worked for others. Try googling "token economy", and see where that leads.
how does A interact with his classmates & other kids? parts of your description sounds like autism spectrum disorder: http://www.nichd.nih.gov/health/topics/asd.cfm
am no expert, but IMHO for such kids, hafta try & understand that they might perceive our world &/or interpret emotions in a very different way, hence the failure to grasp 'mainstream concepts' of what constitutes 'normal socially acceptable behaviour'. what comes naturally to us by a certain developmental age e.g. recognising that others have emotions, 'reading' them (what is happy? what is sad? what is displeasure? etc) & realising that our own actions can have an effect on them...just doesn't come so naturally for them. for all we know, when you shout at the kids - normal kid interpretation = 'you are angry', autistic kid interpretation = 'you are noisy'? think of when you are bringing up Nong Ja, at what ages did she start to show that she understood such concepts.
anyway this is beyond the subfield of neurobiology that i work in (am a scientist)...but my opinion is influenced by seeing how 'totally fearless' mice & fish (created by messing with their genes) are fearless not cos they are 'extremely brave', but cos they are unable to recognise danger & hence unable to learn how to feel fear. for all we know their fellow normal mice & fish see them as 'crazy', just like how some humans brand their autistic counterparts as 'mad'.
Would only suggest assist this kid get some specialist help as you are out of your dept.
Daryle
Hmm.... it sounds like this kid has an overabundance of energy. Could you have the whole class participate in some calesthenics before your period begins?
I'm the mom of an energetic five year old boy, who will go to Kindergarten later this year, and in the USA the schools have recess. The private school I taught at in Thailand, however, did not have recess breaks. They had a snack break in the mid-morning though.
If this is the case at your school and your period is right after snacks, have the kids run around the school field or playground.
When they're this young, they have SOOO much excess energy.
If this isn't possible, maybe try incorporating more physical games into your lessons. Or try tossing a bean bag to a student who you want to answer your question. Keep them on their toes.
I know you're an experienced and dedicated teacher, so my suggestions are ones you may have thought of already. But if not, I hope you might try a few to save your sanity and stay in the good graces of the parents.
Good luck and let us all know how it goes.
Amy
PS: Don't even get me started with that Jesus business. PUKE. I feel the same way you do.
Carpe Diem, we shouldn't lose our temper but we are flesh and bones. I have seen teachers that go off and as you said much more disturbing.
Anon I am sure that even specialists have problems dealing with such students. I will have to google and see what comes up but I don't really know what his problem is...
He interacts normally at times but then others he is a real pain in the butt and kids are yelling at him. He breaks things and destroys other people's work.
Anon 2, thanks for the link and will read with interest.
I agree and see that what I percieve as a normal child and how they react is different to how "A" sees things for sure.
We do label people who are not what we think is normal as mad because we don't understand what is wrong with them.
AMy, I think I could run "A" for an hour and he would still be hypreactive.
Our school has two recess breaks of 15 minutes each day, one moring and one afternoon.
I teach them fist period every day except one where they are last period of the day.
I do play a few different games that make the kids move, and the bean bag sounds good fun and a laugh as I can picture this hitting the kids on teh head at times as Thai kids aren't blessed with co ordination.
Thanks for the suggestions and will keep you updated.
Is there a sport club or something which A could join? If he really has excess energy than maybe his mom could sign him up for activities which use it up.
As for the Jesus thing - I'm an atheist, too, so I suspect the effect of thinking WWJD could be similar to counting to 100. I think many Christians probably believe in a mystical figure: a person who'd generally feel goodwill to others and act in a kind non-violent manner. So I can see how thinking "what would that kind of person do?" might work for the parent you talked to.
That the bible doesn't give an account which would match such a person is another matter. Most Christians neither read the bible nor do they interpret the passages they actually know in a consistent manner. Essentially they project their own world view on a document which was written by a number of authors with widely different world views. Given the actual content of that book, I can only applaud Christians for using that method. Illogical as it may be, it certainly beats the alternative...
You're very patient. I think I woud have actually thrown him out of the window! The kid sounds hyper-active or lacking in parental discipline - the latter of which is very common in Thailand.
These days it seems very common for parents to blame all their children's learning and behavioural difficulties on the teacher, or the government, whilst taking very little responsibility for their own children.
As for what would Jesus do, that just shows how ill-informed his father really is. When I was a kid and going to primary school, if we misbehaved in class the teacher would tell you to told your hand out and wack it with a ruler. Needless to say, there were very few instances of a "lack of concentration".
You have an autistic child on your hands and they require specialist teaching.
I am the father of two boys who are in the autistic spectrum and living with them is not easy specially when they are younger.
Parents who are ignorant of the condition are usually blind as they do not want to think that their children are different.
It is difficult enough in the West to get sufficient support so it must be impossible here in Thailand.
Good luck and do not beat yourself up too much about it. However, one word of advice, do not be too openly judgemental about other people's beliefs as these things have a habit of coming round and biting you in the bum! Lol!
Post a Comment